![A photorealistic image of a rustic wooden workbench by a window overlooking Appalachian hills. On the bench is a kraft envelope with a sketch of a seedling growing from an eggshell, its roots forming a network connecting drawn houses, a clinic cross, a plow, and a radio tower, with labels "Mutual Aid", "Commons", and "Verify" [1]. Around the envelope are a LoRa radio board, a 3D-printed red stethoscope, a hand-welded steel hoe, a USB stick, a magnifying glass on a printout, a fountain pen, and a steaming mug of tea [1].](/media/Gemini_Generated_Image_ykaqqmykaqqmykaq-900x502.jpg)
In the Shell of the Old: Free Software, Open Hardware, and the Infrastructure of Autonomy (2026)
A companion to The Architecture of Resistance, looking from below at the free software and open hardware that self-organized movements build and run themselves: what is documented, what changed in 2024 to 2026, and where the open-source promise runs out.
Published
Contents
A companion to The Architecture of Resistance. That survey looked at liberation technology from above: freedom indices, spyware forensics, protocol roadmaps. This one looks from below, at the free software and open hardware that anarchist, autonomist and other self-organized movements build and run themselves.
1. Introduction: Building Inside the Shell
For these movements, free and open-source software (FOSS) and open-source hardware (OSHW) are more than licensing models. They are prefigurative politics in working form: instead of waiting to seize state or corporate infrastructure, people build parallel, horizontal systems now. The phrase comes from the preamble of the Industrial Workers of the World, which spoke of forming the new society within the shell of the old.
Three things have changed since the first survey was drafted in December 2025, and they shape everything below.
- The money is contested. Much of the movement's core tooling was paid for by one U.S. government grant line, and in 2025 that line was cut, restored by a court, and cut again.
- Crowds reached for Bluetooth mesh. A new open-source app became the default download during blackouts in Nepal, Madagascar, Uganda and Iran, months before its first professional security audit.
- The platforms tightened. Android's move toward mandatory developer registration threatens the side-loading that most of this software depends on.
A caution runs through the whole piece. This field attracts confident claims about which movement used which tool. Many trace back to a single app-store press release or to nothing at all. Section 5 grades each well-known case by the evidence behind it.
2. The Ideological Fit, and Where It Is Loose
State and corporate power lean on information asymmetry, intellectual property monopolies, and chokepoints such as carriers, cloud hosts and app stores. Open ecosystems answer each of these, which is why movements adopt them.
- Commons-based peer production. Peter Kropotkin argued in Mutual Aid (1902) that cooperation, not competition, drives human flourishing. A public repository is a working commons: strangers solve local problems without a chain of command or a profit motive.
- Security through inspection. Under surveillance, software nobody can read is a liability. Open code lets independent researchers look for backdoors and telemetry.
- Refusing artificial scarcity. Publishing design files and schematics under free licenses undercuts monopolies on medicine, communications and tools.
Each point needs a qualifier that movement writing often drops.
- Auditable is not audited. Open code only helps if someone qualified reads it. Two of the most downloaded protest apps of the past seven years were adopted by crowds before any independent review (Sections 5 and 6).
- The license is neutral. The Open Source Definition bars discrimination against persons, groups and fields of endeavor. A tool freed for dissidents is equally free for the police.
- Most of the commons is built on salary. Kernel statistics show the bulk of Linux work comes from paid employees of chip makers and cloud firms, not volunteers (Section 7).
The vocabulary matters here. "Free software" (Richard Stallman, 1983) is an ethical claim about user freedom. "Open source" was coined in 1998 by Christine Peterson to make the same practice easier to sell to business. Many anarchists keep the older term for that reason. "Ethical source" is a third, later camp that adds use restrictions to licenses, which makes the software non-free by both older definitions. That choice has practical costs, as the Reticulum case in Section 4 shows.
3. Software: Counter-Surveillance and Autonomous Infrastructure
The hardened stack is intact, but several of its parts changed hands or died between 2024 and 2026. The table gives the current state of each tool; the notes after it carry the detail.
Tool | What it is | State in late 2026 |
|---|---|---|
Tails | Live operating system on a USB stick; all traffic through Tor; forgets the session on shutdown | Merged into the Tor Project in September 2024 to shed administrative load |
Qubes OS | Laptop system that isolates each activity in its own virtual machine | Active; unchanged in role |
GrapheneOS | Hardened Android without Google services by default | Pixel-only until now; Motorola partnership announced March 2026, first phones expected 2027 |
Signal | End-to-end encrypted messenger on central servers | Usernames now hide the phone number from contacts; post-quantum ratchet added October 2025 |
Briar | Peer-to-peer messenger over Tor, Wi-Fi or Bluetooth | Active; the reference design for blackout messaging |
Manyverse | Secure Scuttlebutt social app | Discontinued; its founder ended work on it in April 2024 |
Matrix, XMPP with OMEMO | Federated chat protocols a collective can self-host | Active |
Delta Chat | Encrypted chat that rides on email servers | Active; a notable performer inside Iran in 2026 |
Mastodon, PeerTube, Mobilizon | ActivityPub social, video and events | Active; Mobilizon passed from Framasoft to Kaihuri in 2024 |
Psiphon Conduit, Tor Snowflake | Volunteer-run bridges for censored users | Active; carried Iran's 2026 circumvention traffic |
Operating systems
Tails remains the standard recommendation for journalists and organizers who need a clean, forgetful session. Its merger with Tor was not a rescue from failure. The team said it had outgrown its structure and wanted to stop spending developer time on fundraising and payroll. That is a recurring theme: small radical projects fail on administration before they fail on code.
GrapheneOS spent 2025 in conflict with states and with its own hardware supplier. The project pulled its infrastructure out of France in November 2025, and it reports that Google is making Pixel ports harder. The Motorola deal is its exit from single-vendor dependence.
Messaging
Signal still requires a phone number to register and still runs on central servers. Both points matter for organizers, and neither has changed. What has changed is that contacts no longer need to see the number.
Briar is the tool this genre of writing usually credits for blackout communication. The documented mass surges tell a different story: they went to Bridgefy in 2019 to 2021 and to Bitchat in 2025 and 2026 (Sections 5 and 6). Briar's design is sounder than either. Its reach is smaller, partly because it has no iPhone version.
Manyverse should come off every recommended list. Its creator announced that his time building Secure Scuttlebutt and the app was over.
Movement-run infrastructure
Riseup (Seattle, 1999) and Autistici/Inventati (Italy, 2001) still provide mail, lists, VPN and collaborative pads on servers they control, with minimal logging. They are the oldest living examples of the prefigurative model: a collective that owns the machines.
Circumvention under shutdown
Iran's blackout that began on 8 January 2026 is the best-documented recent test. After partial connectivity returned, Psiphon peaked near 9.6 million daily users in Iran, fed by diaspora volunteers running Conduit and Snowflake on home connections. During the total shutdown itself, a technical preprint found that no tool depending on ordinary connectivity worked, because the state switched to an allowlist. Volunteer bridges widen a crack. They cannot make one.
Delta Chat held up for a different reason. A Filterwatch report, summarized here, credits it as one of the main working tools because its servers can sit inside the country and keep domestic users talking to each other.
4. Hardware: Material Autonomy
Open hardware carries the same politics into radio, medicine and farm machinery. It is also where the gap between published plans and working, verified equipment is widest.
Mesh radio: one ecosystem became three
Meshtastic is still the entry point. Its firmware is open and runs on LoRa boards that now start under $10, with no carrier or internet needed. Three limits are often left out.
- The radio is not open. LoRa is a patented modulation owned by Semtech. Meshtastic's own developers say so: everything is open except the chip that makes it work.
- The default channel is public. Its key is published, so default group traffic is obscured, not private. Direct messages have used per-node key pairs since version 2.5, without forward secrecy.
- It has had a serious key flaw. CVE-2025-52464 found that some vendors shipped devices with duplicated or low-entropy keys. It was disclosed and patched in 2025.
A LoRa node is also a transmitter. Anyone with a receiver can see that it is on the air and take a bearing on it. "No SIM card" is not the same as "cannot be located."
MeshCore emerged as a rival firmware for the same boards. It routes through dedicated repeaters instead of having every node rebroadcast, which holds up better in dense networks. Reviewers rate its payload encryption as weaker than Meshtastic's. The two do not interoperate.
Reticulum is the most ambitious design: a full cryptographic network stack that runs over LoRa, packet radio, Wi-Fi or anything else. Its 2025 is a case study in fragility. According to a FOSDEM 2026 community session, the founder added anti-AI and no-harm clauses to the license in April 2025, shipped version 1.0 that fall, and withdrew from public engagement in December. The license change keeps the reference code out of Debian and F-Droid and closes off standard open-source grants. Community forks and a Rust rewrite now carry it.
Community-owned networks
Two distinct projects are often merged into one story.
- LibreRouter comes from AlterMundi in Argentina. It is an open-hardware, three-radio mesh router built because commercial routers were being locked against modified firmware. A 2022 grant report counts more than 20 Argentine community networks serving over 13,500 people on LibreRouter and LibreMesh.
- Community cellular in Oaxaca is a different technology. Starting in Talea de Castro in 2013, Zapotec, Mixe and Mixtec villages built their own GSM networks with Rhizomatica and REDES A.C. Their cooperative, Telecomunicaciones Indígenas Comunitarias, won a federal concession in 2016 and is the first licensed community-owned cellular operator of its kind.
Oaxaca is the stronger precedent. It did not route around the state's spectrum monopoly. It forced the regulator to license a commons.
Medicine
Four Thieves Vinegar Collective frames its work as right to repair for the body. Its EpiPencil is an auto-injector assembled from off-the-shelf parts. Its MicroLab is an open-source lab reactor built from common components for $300 to $500, paired with software that proposes synthesis routes. The collective has publicized work on misoprostol and on the hepatitis C cure sofosbuvir.
The claims run ahead of the verification. MicroLab reached version 1.0 in October 2025, yet the collective's own wiki listed one of five recipes as confirmed as of August 2026. Chemists who admire the project point to the missing piece: purification and analytical testing, which the reactor does not do. This is a provocation with real engineering behind it, not yet a pharmacy.
Glia is the opposite case: modest claims, strong evidence. Tarek Loubani's team designed a 3D-printed stethoscope for about $3 that was validated against a market-leading model, then a tourniquet that has been produced and used in Gaza and made for Ukraine. Other devices, including a pulse oximeter, are at earlier stages. Its Gaza workshops have been damaged by bombing more than once, which is the limit of local manufacture under siege.
Farm machinery
L'Atelier Paysan, a French cooperative active since 2009, collects tool designs from working farmers, refines them with staff engineers, publishes the plans, and teaches farmers to weld the tools in workshops. Two details complicate the open-source label. Its plans carry a non-commercial license, which Open Source Ecology's wiki flags as an issue. And its member farmers have declined to develop drones or robots as contrary to the cooperative's values. It is appropriate technology by democratic choice.
Open Source Ecology set out to publish 50 machines that could bootstrap a small modern settlement. After its first decade the project reported 18 of 50 prototyped, with only a handful fully documented. The vision is influential. The set is unfinished.
5. Flashpoints: What the Record Supports
Most movements under pressure used whatever was already on people's phones, and much of it was proprietary. The table grades each well-known case by how well the open-source claim is documented, not by the movement's importance.
Movement | What is documented | What is not | Evidence for the open-source claim |
|---|---|---|---|
Hong Kong, 2019 to 2021 | Bridgefy installs surged, about 60,000 in one week. Telegram and the LIHKG forum carried coordination. After Apple Daily closed in 2021, volunteers archived it on Arweave; RTHK programs were registered through LikeCoin with IPFS storage | Bridgefy, Telegram's servers and LIHKG are not open source. The Apple Daily archive was on Arweave, not IPFS | Weak for the tools, good for the archives |
Myanmar, 2021 to present | Bridgefy reported over a million downloads after the coup. Resistance units fielded 3D-printed FGC-9 carbines, with at least 21 reported incidents through mid-2024. Starlink reached more than 60 resistance-held areas | Organized use of Briar or Meshtastic. I found no solid reporting | Mixed |
Oaxaca, Mexico, 2013 to present | Community-owned GSM networks on open-source software, licensed since 2016, serving dozens of localities | Nothing material | Strong |
Zapatista communities, Chiapas | A support collective reports it moved the communities' communication teams to Linux in 2000, with partial reversal since | A wholesale move of schools and clinics off Microsoft. Asterisk and community cellular belong to Oaxaca, not Chiapas | Moderate, single source |
Rojava (AANES), Syria | A real embargo. Internet arrives by fiber from Iraqi Kurdistan through a licensed provider. Solar is mostly household-scale. Small projects exist, such as offline solar libraries | Open-source microgrids, local intranets, or free software as policy in the academies | Weak |
Sudan, 2019 to present | Resistance committees became the Emergency Response Rooms, which fed hundreds of thousands. They coordinated over WhatsApp, mobile banking apps and Starlink cafes | Briar, Ushahidi or OpenStreetMap as the committees' working stack | Weak for the tools, strong for the mutual aid |
Nepal, Madagascar, Uganda, Iran, 2025 to 2026 | Bitchat download surges during shutdowns and platform bans (Section 6) | How much the app was actually used on the street, as opposed to installed | Strong for adoption |
Iran, 2026 | Millions on Psiphon, Conduit and Snowflake; Delta Chat for domestic traffic; Starlink under jamming (Section 3) | Nothing material | Strong |
Three lessons from the table
Sudan is the hardest case for the thesis, and the most instructive. The Emergency Response Rooms are among the largest working examples of horizontal mutual aid anywhere. When a blackout hit in February 2024, their kitchens began closing, because the money moved through banking apps that needed the network. The politics were horizontal. The infrastructure was not.
Popularity and soundness diverge. Bridgefy was promoted for protests while researchers at Royal Holloway showed its messages could be read and its users tracked. After the company adopted the Signal protocol, the same group broke it again in 2022. Crowds chose it because it was in the app store and took a minute to install.
Satellite, not mesh, restored real connectivity. In Myanmar, Sudan and Iran the lifeline was Starlink, a network owned by one company and one man. Governments have banned its use, states have jammed it, and in Myanmar some resistance administrations restrict it themselves. It is the opposite of a commons, and movements depend on it.
6. What Changed, 2024 to 2026
Four shifts since the first survey bear directly on movements that build their own infrastructure.
The funding base was attacked
The Open Technology Fund is a U.S. government-funded nonprofit that has backed Tor, Signal's early development, F-Droid, Let's Encrypt and most major circumvention tools. Its appropriation is $43.5 million a year, which is 98 percent of its budget.
Date | Event |
|---|---|
November 2025 | Judge Royce Lamberth orders nearly $20 million in withheld fiscal 2025 funds paid by December 1 |
20 June 2025 | The same court grants a preliminary injunction ordering past-due and monthly payments through September |
27 March 2025 | The agency rescinds the termination ahead of a court hearing |
20 March 2025 | OTF sues, saying nearly 150 projects are at risk |
15 March 2025 | The U.S. Agency for Global Media terminates OTF's grant after an executive order |
OTF has survived by litigation, one fiscal year at a time. Open question: I could not confirm its fiscal 2026 funding status from public sources as of this writing.
The episode exposed a contradiction the movement rarely discusses. Tools that anarchists run on their own servers were paid for as an instrument of U.S. foreign policy. When that policy changed, the commons had no second funder of similar size. European sources such as NLnet now carry projects like Mobilizon, at a much smaller scale.
Crowds reached for Bluetooth mesh again
Bitchat, an open-source Bluetooth mesh messenger started by Jack Dorsey, entered beta in July 2025. Within days a researcher showed that users could be impersonated, and the project page gained a warning that it had not been externally reviewed.
Adoption did not wait. Nepal logged nearly 50,000 downloads on 8 September 2025 during its social media ban. Madagascar followed with about 70,000 in a week. In January 2026 a developer reported more than 400,000 downloads in Uganda after opposition leader Bobi Wine urged people to install it before the election, and Iran's blackout brought another wave. A Cure53 audit was reported that same month, with a dozen findings and fixes merged.
Bitchat is a better story than Bridgefy in one respect: the code was open, so the flaws were found, published and fixed in public. Trail of Bits made the balanced case: the early flaws were serious, and open release with fast patching is the right response. Analysts still warn against treating it as a complete answer under a capable state. The download figures come from the developers and measure installs, not use.
The platform tightened
In August 2025 Google announced that apps on certified Android devices must come from developers who have registered their legal identity with Google, including apps installed outside the Play Store. Enforcement began on 30 September 2026 in Brazil, Indonesia, Singapore and Thailand, with wider rollout planned for 2027.
A slower manual path remains for unregistered apps, and F-Droid is not in the first enforcement round. The direction is what matters. F-Droid and the Keep Android Open campaign argue that the policy makes one company the gatekeeper for all Android software. Much of the stack in Section 3 is distributed outside the Play Store, often by developers who have good reason not to hand a government-issued ID to anyone.
This is the choke point the anarchist stack did not plan for. The code is free. The phone is not.
"Open" AI arrived, mostly in name
The first survey called open-source AI the printing press of 2026. The claim needs a qualifier. The Open Source Initiative published its Open Source AI Definition in October 2024, requiring code, weights and enough detail about training data to rebuild an equivalent system. Most models marketed as open, including those from the largest labs, do not meet it. A year on, critics including Bruce Perens, who wrote the original Open Source Definition, said the openwashing continued.
What movements actually gain is narrower and still real: open-weight models that run offline on hardware they own, with no account, no logging and no remote kill switch. What they do not gain is the ability to train one. That takes data centers, which puts the supply-chain problem of Section 7 into a new layer.
7. Tensions and Contradictions
Open source is not a silver bullet, and the people who build these tools say so first. Seven tensions shape the field in 2026.
- Corporate production of the commons. The usual claim is that Meta, Google and Microsoft dominate Linux. The kernel statistics are more specific. Intel has been the top contributor by changesets, followed by Google, Red Hat, Linaro and AMD, and LWN reports that over half of all patches pass through maintainers employed by five companies: two hyperscalers, two chip makers and Red Hat. The commons is real. It is also largely built on corporate payroll for corporate reasons.
- State funding of anti-state tools. Section 6 covers the Open Technology Fund. The dependency predates 2025; that year only made it visible.
- The supply chain wall. Anyone can download a board design. The chips on it come from a few multi-billion-dollar foundries, and the LoRa radio itself is one company's patented technology. Open instruction sets such as RISC-V open the design. They do not open the factory.
- Dual use. Open licenses cannot discriminate by field of endeavor, so the same code serves everyone. ArduPilot, an open-source autopilot begun as a hobby project, guided the drones in Ukraine's June 2025 strike on Russian air bases. One co-founder said he had only wanted to make flying robots. The FGC-9 files that armed Myanmar's resistance are equally available to anyone else.
- The license temptation. Some builders respond by restricting use. Reticulum's no-harm clause and L'Atelier Paysan's non-commercial terms both express real values. Both also take the work outside the free software commons, with concrete costs in distribution and funding (Section 4).
- The single maintainer. Manyverse ended when one person stopped. Reticulum's reference code went quiet when one person withdrew. Tails merged into a larger body to shed the load a small team could not carry. Horizontal movements keep depending on software with a bus factor of one.
- Convenience beats soundness. Under pressure, crowds install what is fastest to get: Bridgefy in 2019, Bitchat in 2025, WhatsApp always. A tool that requires a workshop to set up will lose to one in the app store, whatever its design merits.
The prefigurative claim survives these tensions in a narrower form. Where a community owned the whole system, including the legal standing to operate it, the result has lasted: Oaxaca's cellular cooperative, Argentina's mesh networks, Riseup's servers, Glia's print shops. Where a movement borrowed an app, a satellite link or a grant, it held that capacity only as long as the lender allowed.
Works Cited
Sources consulted 10 November 2026. Links marked in the text point to the page each figure or claim was taken from.
- The Register, Tor Project and Tails merger, 26 September 2024
- Boing Boing, Tor and Tails privacy projects merge, 26 September 2024
- 9to5Google, Motorola confirms GrapheneOS support for a future phone, March 2026
- IT-Connect, Motorola s'allie à GrapheneOS, 2026
- Galaxus, GrapheneOS: good cooperation with Motorola and Qualcomm, problems with Google, 25 August 2026
- Signal, Signal Protocol and Post-Quantum Ratchets, 2 October 2025
- André Staltz, My last update, Manyverse, 5 April 2024
- Mobilizon, News: Kaihuri takes over from Framasoft
- War on the Rocks, Iran's Other Front: The War Over the Internet, 2026
- arXiv, Iran's January 2026 Internet Shutdown: Public Data, Censorship Methods, and Circumvention Techniques, March 2026
- Default Privacy, Getting Online and Staying Private Where the Internet Is Censored, October 2026
- LWN, Meshtastic: off-grid communication for everyone, FOSDEM 2025 report
- RF Lab, MeshCore vs Meshtastic vs Reticulum, July 2026
- Modernizing Tech, Critical Vulnerability in Meshtastic Mesh Networks, 23 June 2025
- Adventure Wiser, Meshtastic vs MeshCore, 2026
- FOSDEM 2026, Reticulum: What's Next? (slides), 2 February 2026
- ARDC, Grant: LibreRouterOS: Mesh-wide vision, May 2022
- GISWatch, Community networks in Mexico
- ITU WSIS, Community Cellular Networks in Oaxaca, Mexico
- Slashdot, summarizing 404 Media, The Rise of DIY, Pirated Medicine, 4 September 2024
- Wikipedia, Four Thieves Vinegar Collective
- STAT, Glia Project: tourniquets and stethoscopes in Gaza, 31 October 2023
- Glia, 3D printed tourniquet repository
- Vice, Makers of 3D-Printed Medical Equipment Struggle to Save Lives in Gaza Under Siege, October 2023
- Resilience, Making, Adapting, Sharing: Fabricating Open-Source Agricultural Tools, 6 July 2018
- Open Source Ecology wiki, Atelier Paysan and Status Update
- L'Atelier Paysan, Designing a tool or building
- Quartz, Hong Kong protestors use Bridgefy to preempt internet shutdown, September 2019
- Royal Holloway, Cryptographers urge caution over use of secure messaging app
- Albrecht, Eikenberg and Paterson, Breaking Bridgefy, again, USENIX Security 2022
- The Block, Supporters of Hong Kong's Apple Daily are storing its archives on a blockchain, 24 June 2021
- Forkast, Back up Hong Kong: How blockchain has quietly become history's hard drive
- The Diplomat, The Impact of Technological Weapons in the Myanmar Conflict, April 2025
- Radio Free Asia, Anti-junta forces set up satellite-based internet service in 60 areas, December 2023
- BNI, Digital Repression Persists Across Junta and Resistance-Controlled Areas in Myanmar
- Institute of Network Cultures, Digital Tribulations 19: Tierra y Señal, 27 May 2026
- SMEX, Lost telecommunications amidst belligerent groups in Northeast Syria
- Poor Proles Almanac, Ecological Revolution in Rojava
- ASU News, Solar-powered libraries help Syrian communities rebuild from war, April 2023
- The New Humanitarian, How mutual aid networks are powering Sudan's humanitarian response, 2 August 2023
- The New Humanitarian, Communication blackout thwarts mutual aid efforts in besieged Khartoum, 4 March 2024
- Developing Telecoms, Telecoms shutdown making Sudan's humanitarian crisis worse: NGOs
- Heise, After Trump's decree: fight for US funding for Tor, F-Droid and Let's Encrypt, 25 March 2025
- Open Technology Fund, OTF files lawsuit to contest grant termination, 21 March 2025
- The Diplomat, USAGM Reverses Course on RFE/RL and OTF Grant Terminations, March 2025
- Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, Open Technology Fund v. Lake
- Bloomberg Law, Open Technology Fund Succeeds in Bid for US Agency's Payments, November 2025
- Wikipedia, BitChat
- Cryptonews, Bitchat dev shrugs off Uganda's threat to block app, January 2026
- Nostr Compass, Issue 5: Bitchat completes Cure53 security audit, January 2026
- Trail of Bits, Building secure messaging is hard: a nuanced take on the Bitchat security debate, 18 July 2025
- BISI, Bitchat: Bluetooth Mesh Networks and Internet Shutdowns, 27 January 2026
- Gadget Hacks, Google Didn't Ban Android Sideloading: Here's What Changed Sept. 30, October 2026
- Wikipedia, Keep Android Open
- Open Source Initiative, The Open Source AI Definition 1.0
- SiliconANGLE, OSI clarifies what makes AI systems open-source, but most "open" models fall short, 28 October 2024
- FOSS Force, A year after OSAID 1.0, critics still aren't sold, 2025
- LWN, Some 6.10 development statistics and maintainer statistics
- It's FOSS, This Open Source Software Was Used in Ukraine's Drone Attack on Russia, June 2025