Linocut of a child’s bed with a blanket, a red thread across the pillow

Reparenting and the Nervous System: What Helps, and How Well We Know It

Chapter 12 of Generational Liberation. Giving yourself what you did not get, and calming a body that learned to expect danger. What reparenting is, which treatments for trauma are well tested and which are promising or contested, and what none of them can do alone.

Published

Contents
  1. What reparenting is
  2. Self-compassion
  3. The body learns too
  4. What is well tested
  5. What is promising
  6. What is contested
  7. Two things you can do today
  8. What this cannot do
  9. Reader exercise
  10. Resources
  11. Works cited

Part IV, The Work. Chapter 12 of Generational Liberation: Healing the American Family.

Jessica is a composite, drawn from patterns that recur in accounts of therapy. She is not a real person.

Jessica is 29. She is sitting on a therapist's couch with her eyes closed, feeling ridiculous. She has been asked to picture herself at seven, the year her father left, and to speak to that child.

"I'm talking to myself," she says.

She tries again. She pictures the small bedroom, the girl on the bed. In her mind she sits down beside her and says what nobody said at the time: It wasn't your fault. He left because he couldn't manage his own life. It had nothing to do with whether you were lovable.

She is surprised to find that she is crying. She has believed the opposite for twenty-two years.

This is called reparenting. This chapter describes it, and then turns to the body, because a childhood spent on alert leaves its mark there too. Throughout, it tries to be plain about how good the evidence is. Some of what is offered to people in pain is well tested. Some is promising. Some is popular and unproven. You are entitled to know which is which.

What reparenting is

The idea is simple. A child needs certain things from the adults around her. Two well-known writers on parenting sum them up as four: to be safe, seen, soothed and secure. When those are missing, the need does not expire. Reparenting means supplying them to yourself, as an adult, on purpose.

In practice it looks like this:

  • Noticing. Asking, once a day, how am I, and what do I need? Many people raised in troubled homes were never asked.
  • Answering the critic. The harsh voice in your head often uses a parent's phrases. You can learn to recognize it and reply as a decent parent would.
  • Soothing. Finding what calms you, and doing it without having to earn it.
  • Keeping your word to yourself. Trust is built by small promises kept.
  • Setting limits. See The Cycle Breakers.

Reparenting is a way of working used inside several kinds of therapy, and a habit people practice on their own. It has not been tested as a treatment in its own right. Its closest relative with a research record is self-compassion.

Self-compassion

The psychologist Kristin Neff describes self-compassion as three things: treating yourself kindly when you struggle, remembering that struggle is ordinary and shared, and noticing a painful feeling without drowning in it.

A review that pooled 20 samples found a strong link between self-compassion and mental health. People higher in it had markedly fewer symptoms of depression, anxiety and stress.[1] That is a correlation. It does not prove that practicing kindness toward yourself will make you well. It does suggest that the harsh inner voice is not, as many of us were taught, what keeps us in line.

The body learns too

A child who grows up braced for a slammed door or a sudden silence becomes an adult who startles easily, sleeps lightly and reads danger into a neutral face. This is the body doing what it was trained to do.

It is also where a great deal of confident popular writing outruns the science. Three cautions.

First, tidy accounts of which brain region does what are simplifications. Second, the claim that therapy "rewires" the brain or "reverses" inherited biology is a hope, not an established result; The Epigenetic Inheritance sets out how limited the human evidence on inheritance is. Third, the encouraging evidence that a better environment can repair early harm comes mostly from children moved out of deprivation young, as in the Romanian study in Attachment Theory for a Nation, and from laboratory animals. Adults can change. How much, and by what route, is less settled than the bestsellers suggest.

What is well tested

For post-traumatic stress, the strongest guidance in the United States comes from the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense, which reviewed the trial evidence in 2023. They recommend three talking treatments above all others, and above medication: prolonged exposure, cognitive processing therapy, and eye movement desensitization and reprocessing, known as EMDR.[2]

All three involve going back to the memory with a trained person, in a structured way, until it loses its grip. In EMDR the person holds the memory in mind while following a side-to-side movement. Why the eye movements should matter is still argued over. That the treatment helps is not.

Two things follow. These treatments were tested mainly on PTSD, which is narrower than "a difficult childhood." And they are done with a clinician. Tapping your own shoulders while recalling the worst day of your life is not EMDR, and this book does not recommend it.

What is promising

Yoga. In one trial, 64 women with long-standing PTSD that had not responded to years of treatment were assigned to ten weeks of either trauma-informed yoga or health education classes. Afterward, 52 percent of the yoga group no longer met the criteria for PTSD, against 21 percent of the others.[3] It is one study, of women only, and yoga was added to their care, not substituted for it.

Somatic Experiencing. This approach works with bodily sensation instead of the story. A 2021 review found 16 usable studies and called the results promising, while noting that study quality was mixed and that more rigorous trials are needed.[4]

What is contested

Polyvagal theory. Many therapists now explain distress as a ladder of three bodily states: calm and sociable, fight or flight, and shutdown. People often find this picture a relief, because it turns "what is wrong with me" into "what state am I in." As a description of experience it can be useful. As physiology it is disputed. A 2023 review by a specialist in the field argued that each of the theory's basic premises is untenable or highly implausible on the evidence.[5] The theory's author rejects that critique. Use the map if it helps. Do not mistake it for settled science.

Parenting courses built on attachment. The Circle of Security teaches parents to be both a secure base and a safe haven. Its picture of what a child needs is sound. But when its short group version was tested with 141 mothers in Head Start, it did not, overall, change children's attachment or behavior. Mothers did report fewer unsupportive reactions to their children's distress.[6]

Two things you can do today

These are ordinary grounding techniques, widely taught. They are not treatment. If either makes you feel worse, stop.

Slow the breath. Breathe in through the nose for a count of four and out for a count of six or eight. Continue for two minutes.

Look around. Turn your head slowly. Name five things you can see, four you can hear, three you can feel. Then say, if it is true: right now, in this room, I am safe.

What this cannot do

  • It cannot replace treatment for severe trauma. Deep work with painful memories can make things worse before it makes them better, and should be done with help.
  • It cannot replace other people. The Cycle Breakers showed that steady relationships are what break cycles. A kinder relationship with yourself prepares you for those. It does not stand in for them.
  • It cannot fix what is not inside you. No breathing exercise lowers the rent (When One Income Stopped Being Enough).
  • It is slow. Expect years.

Reader exercise

Take twenty minutes. If it stirs up more than you expected, stop, and talk with someone you trust.

  • Of the four needs, safe, seen, soothed, secure, which was most reliably met when you were small? Which least?
  • Write down one sentence your inner critic says often. Whose voice is it?
  • Write the reply a kind and sensible parent would give.

Resources

If you are in crisis: call or text 988.

  • National Center for PTSD (treatment information for anyone, not only veterans): ptsd.va.gov
  • EMDR International Association therapist directory: emdria.org
  • SAMHSA National Helpline: 1-800-662-4357
  • Books: Kristin Neff, Self-Compassion; Daniel Siegel and Tina Payne Bryson, The Power of Showing Up

This chapter is educational. It is not medical advice.

Jessica did not walk out of that room healed. She walked out having heard, for the first time, a true sentence about herself. The rest is repetition: the same sentence, said again, until the body starts to believe it.

Previous: The Cycle Breakers. Next: Healing Together.

Works cited

  1. MacBeth A, Gumley A. "Exploring compassion: A meta-analysis of the association between self-compassion and psychopathology." Clinical Psychology Review 32(6):545-552, 2012. https://eprints.gla.ac.uk/64162
  2. Schnurr PP, Hamblen JL, et al. "The Management of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Acute Stress Disorder: Synopsis of the 2023 U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and U.S. Department of Defense Clinical Practice Guideline." Annals of Internal Medicine 177(3):363-374, 2024. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38408360/
  3. van der Kolk BA, Stone L, West J, Rhodes A, Emerson D, Suvak M, Spinazzola J. "Yoga as an Adjunctive Treatment for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A Randomized Controlled Trial." Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 75(6):e559-e565, 2014. Summary: https://gap.hks.harvard.edu/yoga-adjunctive-treatment-posttraumatic-stress-disorder-randomized-controlled-trial
  4. Kuhfuß M, Maldei T, Hetmanek A, Baumann N. "Somatic experiencing: effectiveness and key factors of a body-oriented trauma therapy: a scoping literature review." European Journal of Psychotraumatology 12(1):1929023, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1080/20008198.2021.1929023
  5. Grossman P. "Fundamental challenges and likely refutations of the five basic premises of the polyvagal theory." Biological Psychology 180:108589, 2023. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37230290/
  6. Cassidy J, Brett BE, Gross JT, Stern JA, Martin DR, Mohr JJ, Woodhouse SS. "Circle of Security-Parenting: A randomized controlled trial in Head Start." Development and Psychopathology 29(2):651-673, 2017. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5543687