
Attachment Theory for a Nation: Why America's Relationship Problems Start in Infancy
Chapter 4 of Generational Liberation. What attachment research shows about how early care shapes adult relationships, how common insecure attachment really is, what is known and not known about its reach into work and politics, and why it is not a life sentence.
Published
Contents
Chapter 4 of Generational Liberation: Healing the American Family.
By three months old, a baby is collecting evidence on one question. When I cry, does someone come? Is it the same someone? Do they comfort me, or are they angry?
The question gets answered thousands of times before the child can speak. Out of the answers the child builds a working model of what other people are like and what he or she is worth to them. That model is what psychologists call attachment.
This chapter is about what attachment research shows, how far it can fairly be stretched, and what it would mean to take it seriously as a country.
Four patterns
Attachment theory began with the British psychiatrist John Bowlby and was put on an observational footing by the psychologist Mary Ainsworth. It describes four broad patterns.
Secure. Care was reliable and warm. The child learns: I matter, people can be trusted. As adults, secure people are comfortable both with closeness and with being alone. They can ask for help and give it.
Anxious. Care was inconsistent: sometimes there, sometimes not. The child learns to watch constantly and to protest loudly. As adults, anxious people fear being left, need reassurance, and read rejection into small things.
Avoidant. Care was cold or dismissive. The child learns not to expect comfort and to rely on no one. As adults, avoidant people prize independence, keep partners at a distance, and withdraw when things get difficult.
Disorganized. The caregiver was also the source of fear. The child faces a problem with no solution. As adults, these people swing between craving closeness and dreading it.
These are tendencies, not types of person. Most of us show more than one, depending on the relationship and the day.
How common is insecure attachment?
It is often said that most Americans are insecurely attached. The best evidence says otherwise.
The one study to classify a nationally representative sample of American adults found 59 percent secure, 25 percent avoidant and 11 percent anxious.[1] So secure attachment is the majority experience. A large minority, around two in five, falls outside it.
Where things go badly wrong, the picture is different. About 15 percent of infants in ordinary samples show the disorganized pattern. Among children who have been maltreated, the figure reaches roughly 80 to 90 percent.[2]
That is the honest shape of the problem. Not a nation of the insecure, but a secure majority, a substantial insecure minority, and a smaller group carrying the heaviest load, concentrated where childhood was most dangerous.
What disrupts it
A review of the research on adverse caregiving, running from infancy to old age, ties maltreatment and institutional rearing to insecure and disorganized attachment, and to lasting difficulty in relationships in childhood, adolescence and adult life.[2]
The most extreme case is the orphanage. A long-running study followed 136 Romanian children who had been abandoned to institutions as infants. Among those whose placements kept changing after the age of two and a half, more moves predicted more behavior problems at twelve. The effects were small, and the study could not prove cause.[3]
Closer to home is the parent's own history. In a study of 146 American mothers of young children, those with more adversity in their own childhoods reported harsher parenting, and the link ran through an insecure bond with the child. The authors are careful about its limits: one point in time, self-report, a mostly white and middle-class sample.[4] It is suggestive all the same. A parent's old injury reaches the child by way of the relationship between them.
Beyond that, the argument is one of common sense more than data. Attunement takes attention, and attention is what exhaustion, money trouble, depression and addiction use up first. A parent working two jobs is not a bad parent. But there are only so many hours in which to notice a child.
At home and at work
The self-fulfilling quality of insecure attachment is its cruelest feature. The anxious partner, afraid of being left, clings and tests until the other pulls away. The avoidant partner, expecting to be let down, invests little and gets little back. Each ends up with proof of what they already believed.
It would be surprising if the same habits stopped at the office door. An anxious employee may need more reassurance than a manager thinks to give. An avoidant one may do fine alone and struggle on a team. A manager who is steady, available and fair works on people much as a good parent does. Research on attachment at work exists and points this way, but it is a younger field, and this paragraph should be read as a reasonable extension, not an established result.
What about politics?
Here the evidence is thinner still, and it is worth saying exactly what it is.
One study inferred the attachment styles of members of Congress who served between 2013 and 2021 by running their public Twitter posts through a machine-learning model. Members scored as anxious were less likely to work across party lines. Members scored as avoidant were more likely to. The authors suggest that anxious politicians cling to the party for fear of rejection. They also point out that politicians do not always write their own tweets.[5]
A separate study of ordinary adults looked for a link between attachment style and political ideology and found no consistent one. Secure people turned up among both liberals and conservatives.[6]
So the fair summary is this. Attachment may shape how people behave inside a political tribe: how tightly they hold to it, how much they fear stepping out of line. There is no good evidence that it decides which tribe they join. Anyone who tells you that polarization is simply a nation's childhood wounds has gone past what is known.
Not a life sentence
Attachment patterns are durable. They are not fixed. Adults who began insecurely and became secure are common enough that researchers have a name for it: earned security. It tends to come through a long, steady relationship, with a partner, a mentor, a therapist or a fellowship, in which the old expectations are quietly proved wrong.
For parents who want to give what they did not get, there are programs built for the purpose. Researchers in the field point to Circle of Security, Attachment and Biobehavioral Catch-Up, the Group Attachment Based Intervention and Child-Parent Psychotherapy.[4] The review cited above finds that foster care, Child-Parent Psychotherapy and attachment-based programs can improve attachment and social functioning in children who started badly.[2]
The sentence to hold on to is that you do not need to have had a secure childhood in order to give one.
A nation that took this seriously
If early care matters this much, then the conditions under which parents give it are a public question. This is an argument, and the later chapters on work and money make it at length. In brief:
- Paid leave, so that a parent can be there in the months when the first question is being answered.
- Wages and hours that leave a parent something to give at the end of the day.
- Stable housing, because a child cannot settle if the household cannot.
- Treatment for parents, for depression, addiction and trauma, as a service to their children.
- Help offered early to families under the most strain, where the heaviest load falls.
Reader exercise
Set aside half an hour. If this stirs up more than you expected, stop, and talk with someone you trust or with a therapist.
Then. When you were small and upset, what happened? Could you predict it?
Now. In your closest relationship, do you move toward the other person when things are hard, or away? What are you afraid of?
Next. Who in your life has been reliably there? What would it take for you to be that for someone else?
Resources
If you are in crisis: call or text 988.
- Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families: adultchildren.org
- National Child Traumatic Stress Network: nctsn.org
- SAMHSA National Helpline: 1-800-662-4357
This chapter is educational. It is not medical advice and is not a substitute for care from a qualified professional.
A baby's first question is whether anyone will come. Most American children get a good enough answer. Too many do not, and they carry the answer they got into every room they enter for the rest of their lives, unless someone, eventually, gives them a better one.
Previous: Adult Children of America. Next: When One Income Stopped Being Enough.
Works cited
- Mickelson KD, Kessler RC, Shaver PR. "Adult attachment in a nationally representative sample." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 73(5):1092-1106, 1997. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9364763/
- Doyle C, Cicchetti D. "From the Cradle to the Grave: The Effect of Adverse Caregiving Environments on Attachment and Relationships Throughout the Lifespan." Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 24(2):203-217, 2017. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5600283/
- Almas AN, Papp LJ, Woodbury MR, Nelson CA, Zeanah CH, Fox NA. "The Impact of Caregiving Disruptions of Previously Institutionalized Children on Multiple Outcomes in Late Childhood." Child Development 91(1):96-109, 2020. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7197095/
- Khan M, Renk K. "Breaking the Cycle: Could Attachment Disrupt the Intergenerational Transmission of Adverse Childhood Experiences?" Perspectives in Infant Mental Health, 28 February 2020. https://perspectives.waimh.org/2020/02/28/breaking-the-cycle-could-attachment-disrupt-the-intergenerational-transmission-of-adverse-childhood-experiences/
- Dolan EW. "Anxiously attached members of Congress exhibit reduced bipartisanship." PsyPost, 9 March 2024, reporting Gruda D, Hanges P, et al., Personality and Individual Differences. https://www.psypost.org/anxiously-attached-members-of-congress-exhibit-reduced-bipartisanship/
- Gaziano C. "Adult Attachment Style and Political Ideology." SAGE Open, 2017. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2158244017724493