adult-children-of-americainocut of a large chair beside a small chair, a red thread running through both

Adult Children of America: How Common Is the Dysfunctional Family?

Chapter 3 of Generational Liberation. The claim that 70 to 80 percent of American families are dysfunctional has no survey behind it. What can be counted is striking enough, and it explains why so many adults recognize themselves in the idea of the adult child.

Published

Contents
  1. What can be counted
  2. What "dysfunctional" means
  3. The adult child
  4. Survival skills, not defects
  5. The Johnson family: a composite
  6. An argument about the country
  7. Reader exercise
  8. What recovery asks
  9. Resources
  10. Works cited

Chapter 3 of Generational Liberation: Healing the American Family.

There is a number you will meet in almost any book or website about family dysfunction: 70 to 80 percent of Americans come from dysfunctional families. Sometimes it is 96 percent. It is quoted as if it were a finding.

It is not. The figure circulates as an estimate attributed to addiction counselors and recovery writers of the 1980s and 1990s, and as the result of unnamed "polls". No survey stands behind it. It persists because it feels true to a great many people, and that feeling is worth taking seriously. But a book that asks you to look honestly at your family should start by being honest about its numbers.

So this chapter asks the question properly. How common is a troubled childhood in America, and what does it do to the adults who had one?

What can be counted

The best evidence comes from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which asked adults in all 50 states about adverse childhood experiences. Nearly two thirds, 63.9 percent, reported at least one. About one in six, 17.3 percent, reported four or more.[1]

The particulars matter. About a third of adults, 34.0 percent, said they had been emotionally abused as children. 28.4 percent had been through a parental separation or divorce. And 26.5 percent grew up in a household with substance abuse.[1]

That last figure is not a relic of the past. Federal survey data from 2009 to 2014 found that about 8.7 million children, roughly one in eight, were living with at least one parent who had a substance use disorder. For about 7.5 million of them, the disorder involved alcohol.[2]

None of this supports "70 to 80 percent of families are dysfunctional". One adverse experience does not make a family dysfunctional, and plenty of harm falls outside what the surveys ask about. What the data does support is a plainer statement: a difficult childhood is the common American experience, not the exception, and a large minority grew up with several kinds of trouble at once.

What "dysfunctional" means

Dysfunction is a matter of degree. Every family has bad years. The word is useful for families in which certain conditions are the settled climate and not the weather:

  • A parent who is there and not there. Physically present, emotionally unreachable.
  • Unpredictability. Children never know which parent is coming through the door.
  • Boundaries that are missing or rigid. Either nobody has a self, or nobody can get close.
  • Roles turned upside down. A child looks after a parent's moods, or a parent's drinking, or the younger children.
  • Things that cannot be said. The family runs on what everyone knows and nobody mentions.
  • Worth that has to be earned. Love depends on performance, appearance or silence.

Notice that addiction and violence are not on the list, though they produce everything on it. A sober, employed, outwardly successful household can meet every one of these conditions.

The adult child

In the late 1970s, a group of people who had grown up with alcoholic parents began meeting in New York and found they shared a set of traits. One of them wrote those traits down. The list became known as the Laundry List, and the fellowship that grew around it is Adult Children of Alcoholics and Dysfunctional Families, or ACA.[3]

The "dysfunctional families" in the name was the important discovery. People who had never lived with a drinker read the list and recognized themselves.

The Laundry List belongs to ACA, and it is best read in the fellowship's own words on its own site.[4] In outline, it describes adults who:

  • are afraid of authority figures and of anger, and will do a great deal to avoid criticism;
  • seek approval so habitually that they lose track of what they themselves want;
  • feel responsible for everyone else and guilty when they stand up for themselves;
  • are drawn to people who need rescuing, and mistake pity for love;
  • learned to stop feeling in childhood and have trouble feeling now;
  • judge themselves without mercy;
  • fear abandonment enough to stay in relationships that hurt them.

The phrase "adult child" does not mean childish. It means an adult who meets the present with reactions formed in childhood.

Survival skills, not defects

Every trait on that list once solved a problem. A child who can read a parent's mood from the sound of the car door is safer than one who cannot. A child who never asks for anything is less likely to be a target. A child who looks after everyone is needed, and being needed is the next best thing to being loved.

The trouble comes later, when the danger is gone and the reflex remains. The hypervigilant child becomes the employee who cannot hear feedback without dread. The child who asked for nothing becomes the spouse who cannot say what she wants.

This is the most useful idea in the recovery tradition. You are not broken. You adapted, intelligently, to a situation that no longer exists.

Writers on family systems have also described the roles children take up in such households: the hero who makes the family look good, the scapegoat who carries the blame, the lost child who disappears, the mascot who defuses tension with a joke. Most adult children can name theirs without difficulty.

The Johnson family: a composite

The Johnsons are a composite, drawn from patterns that recur in accounts of family life across generations. They are not real people.

Robert, born in 1920, came through the Depression and the war, drank to keep it down, and raised three children who were afraid of him.

His son William, born in 1950, swore he would be nothing like his father. He became a tireless, anxious, approval-seeking manager, and at home a father so determined to be involved that his children could not get free of him.

William's daughter Rachel, born in 1982, grew up unable to make a decision without checking. At 24 she went into therapy. When she had a child of her own she set limits with her father, which felt like cruelty and was not.

Her daughter Emma, born in 2015, is growing up with a mother who can say what she feels. Some of what came down the line has stopped. Not all of it. That is what progress in a family usually looks like.

An argument about the country

What follows is an argument, not a finding. No study has measured it.

If most American adults carry some of this, it would be strange if it stayed at home. Workplaces fill with conscientious people who cannot say no and managers who replay their fathers. Public life rewards whoever offers the frightened child inside the voter a strong parent or a clear enemy. Neighbors who learned early that other people are dangerous do not easily form communities.

Read that as a way of looking, not as proof. Later chapters test parts of it against what evidence exists.

Reader exercise

Read ACA's Laundry List on the fellowship's site. Then, with a notebook and about half an hour:

  1. Mark the traits that are plainly yours. Pick the three strongest.
  2. For each, ask: what was happening at home that made this necessary? How did it protect me?
  3. Ask where it shows up now: at work, with a partner, with your children.
  4. Ask what it costs you, and what you are afraid would happen if you put it down.

This is not an exercise in blame, of your parents or yourself. If it brings up more than you expected, stop, and talk with someone you trust or with a therapist.

What recovery asks

  • Seeing it. Naming the pattern as a pattern.
  • Grieving. For the childhood you did not get.
  • Help. A therapist, a fellowship, or both.
  • New skills. Saying what you feel. Saying no. Staying in the room during a disagreement.
  • Company. People further along the same road.
  • Patience. What took eighteen years to learn does not unlearn in a season.

Resources

If you are in crisis: call or text 988.

  • Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families: adultchildren.org. Meetings in person, online and by phone.
  • Al-Anon Family Groups: al-anon.org
  • Co-Dependents Anonymous: coda.org
  • SAMHSA National Helpline: 1-800-662-4357

This chapter is an independent work. It is not ACA literature and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families World Service Organization. It is educational and is not a substitute for care from a qualified professional.

We do not know that 70 or 80 percent of American families are dysfunctional. We do know that most American adults had something hard happen in childhood, that a great many had a lot, and that there is now a language, a set of tools and a fellowship for dealing with it. Earlier generations had none of the three.

Previous: The Therapy Gap. Next: Attachment Theory for a Nation.

Works cited

  1. Swedo EA, Aslam MV, Dahlberg LL, et al. "Prevalence of Adverse Childhood Experiences Among U.S. Adults: Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System, 2011-2020." MMWR 72(26):707-715, 2023. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/72/wr/mm7226a2.htm
  2. Lipari RN, Van Horn SL. "Children Living with Parents Who Have a Substance Use Disorder." The CBHSQ Report, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, 2017. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29144715/
  3. Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families World Service Organization. https://adultchildren.org/
  4. Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families World Service Organization. "The Laundry List." https://adultchildren.org/laundry-list/