Linocut of a duffel bag and a cap on the floor, a red thread passing between them

The Therapy Gap: Why Baby Boomers' Parents Couldn't Heal, and How It Shaped America

Chapter 2 of Generational Liberation. The generation that came home from the Depression, World War II and Korea raised its children before family therapy was within reach of ordinary people. What that gap cost, how much of it is still open, and how to look at it with both accountability and compassion.

Published

Contents
  1. Family therapy arrived late
  2. What the war left behind
  3. Silence as a survival skill
  4. The gap is still open
  5. The Williams family: a composite
  6. Reader exercise: the therapy gap in your family
  7. Accountability and compassion
  8. Closing the gap
  9. Resources
  10. Works cited

Chapter 2 of Generational Liberation: Healing the American Family.

James and the families described in this chapter are composites, drawn from patterns that recur in accounts of postwar family life. They are not real people, and nothing here is an interview.

James came home from Korea in 1952 with nightmares, a hair-trigger startle and a numbness he could not explain. His doctor gave him sleeping pills. His priest told him to pray. His father, who had been to war himself, told him to buck up. Nobody suggested he talk to anyone about what he had seen, because in his world that was not a thing people did.

He married, raised four children, and for forty years was a distant father who erupted when his control slipped. His children were afraid of him and confused by him. They knew something was wrong and had no name for it. He died without ever being treated.

Multiply James by millions. The parents of the Baby Boom had lived through the Depression and at least one war, and had built rigid ways of coping in order to get through. Then they raised children at a time when help for ordinary people with ordinary trauma barely existed. This chapter calls that the therapy gap: the years when families most needed treatment that could interrupt what they were passing on, and it was not there.

Family therapy arrived late

The idea that a family is a system, that one member's unhealed injury shapes everyone else, and that you might treat the whole household together, is recent. Psychoanalysis, the dominant approach in the first half of the twentieth century, treated one person at a time.

Nathan Ackerman, trained as a classical analyst, began seeing patients together with their families shortly after World War II. The institute that carries his name, set up so he could train others, was founded in 1960.[1] Other pioneers, among them Murray Bowen, Virginia Satir and Salvador Minuchin, developed their own approaches over the following decades.

Set those dates against the Baby Boom. In 1960 the oldest Boomers were fourteen. Their parents' habits as parents were long settled. And for years afterward, family therapy remained something practiced in a handful of cities, for people with money and time. A steelworker in Ohio or a farm family in West Virginia had no route to it, and would not have taken one if they had.

What the war left behind

We do not have to guess whether combat stayed with these men. In the 1990s, researchers studied 1,210 veterans of World War II and Korea who were part of a long-running study of aging. More than half of the World War II veterans reported combat experience. Forty-five years after the war, those who had seen moderate or heavy combat were about thirteen times as likely to report PTSD symptoms as veterans who had seen none.[2]

Nor does it always fade. In a national study of American veterans aged 55 and older, about one in ten experienced a clinically significant worsening of PTSD symptoms late in life, on average nearly three decades after the trauma.[3] Retirement, illness and loss can bring back what work and routine held down.

These are the symptoms. What a family lived with was their shape at home: the father who could not be startled, the subject that could not be raised, the drinking, the temper, the long silences. Wives carried their own load. They had run households alone, waited for telegrams, and then lived with men who came back changed.

Silence as a survival skill

The Depression and the war rewarded a particular kind of toughness. Do not complain. Do not burden others. Get on with it. Those were real skills, and they kept people alive.

Carried into family life, they did damage. A child who is told "you're fine, stop crying" every time she is hurt does not learn to handle feelings. She learns to bury them. A father who equates emotion with weakness can be in the house every evening and still be out of reach.

The parenting style of the period fit the same mold. Psychologists call it authoritarian: strict rules, physical punishment, obedience without explanation, little warmth. It is the opposite of what the research favors, which is authoritative parenting, firm and warm together. Authoritarian parenting was not cruelty in the eyes of those who practiced it. It was how they had been raised, and it was the only model on offer.

Behind all of it stood stigma. To see a psychiatrist in 1955 was to be thought crazy. If you were struggling you spoke to a minister, or more likely to no one. And for most families the money was not there in any case.

The gap is still open

It is tempting to treat all this as history. The numbers say otherwise.

In 2019, a federal survey found that 19.2 percent of American adults had received some mental health treatment in the past year. Most of that was medication: 15.8 percent had taken it, while 9.5 percent had received counseling or therapy.[4]

The age pattern is the telling part. Counseling or therapy was reported by 11.6 percent of adults aged 18 to 44, by 9.1 percent of those aged 45 to 64, and by 5.7 percent of those 65 and over. Women were more likely than men to have received any treatment.[4]

So older Americans do get help. They get it as a prescription from a family doctor, far more often than as a conversation. That is the therapy gap in its present form. The generation raised by the silent parents will accept a pill, which is medical and therefore respectable, and still balks at the thing their parents taught them was weakness.

The Williams family: a composite

Robert, born in 1925, fought in the Pacific. He came home, drank, raged, and was never treated.

His son David, born in 1951, grew up walking on eggshells. He became an anxious adult who could not bring himself to see anyone about it. His father's voice was in his head. He finally went at 45, when a crisis at work left him no choice, and came to see his father as a wounded man. By then he had raised his own daughter with the over-watchfulness of a man who never felt safe.

That daughter, Sarah, born in 1985, started therapy at 22. She is the first in three generations to get help before having children of her own.

The counterfactual is easy to state and impossible to prove: had Robert been treated in 1945, David might have grown up secure, and Sarah might never have needed to untangle any of it. What the story does show is the direction of travel. Each generation reached help a little earlier than the one before.

Reader exercise: the therapy gap in your family

Take half an hour with a notebook. If this brings up more than you expected, stop, and talk it over with someone you trust or with a therapist.

Your grandparents. What did they live through? Did any of them ever get help of any kind? If not, what stood in the way: money, distance, shame, or simply not knowing it existed?

Your parents. What did they absorb about feelings and about asking for help? Did they ever seek treatment? What did it take?

You. Have you? What made it possible, or what is stopping you?

The turn. Who was the first person in your family to get help, and what had to change for that to happen?

Accountability and compassion

Understanding the therapy gap asks you to hold two things at once.

The first is that harm was done. Children raised by frightened, silent or violent parents were hurt, and their struggles as adults are real consequences, not weakness.

The second is that those parents were working with what they had. They were given no treatment, were taught that needing it was shameful, and parented the way they had been parented.

People who work through this often describe grieving twice. Once for what a parent could not give. And again on understanding why. Both griefs are legitimate. Neither cancels the other.

Closing the gap

We cannot treat the dead. We can keep the gap from reopening.

  1. Make treatment affordable, so that cost is not what decides who heals.
  2. Reach older adults where they already are, which is the family doctor's office.
  3. Treat families, not only individuals, when the problem runs through a household.
  4. Speak to men directly. The stigma fell hardest on them and has lifted least.
  5. Take care of veterans early, not forty-five years on.

Resources

If you are in crisis: call or text 988. Veterans can call 988 and press 1 for the Veterans Crisis Line.

  • SAMHSA National Helpline: 1-800-662-4357. Free, confidential treatment referral.
  • National Center for PTSD: ptsd.va.gov
  • National Alliance on Mental Illness: nami.org
  • Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families: adultchildren.org
  • Al-Anon Family Groups: al-anon.org

This chapter is educational. It is not medical advice and is not a substitute for care from a qualified professional.

Untreated trauma does not disappear. It is handed on. The healing one generation cannot reach becomes the work of the next. That is the lesson of the therapy gap, and the reason not to let it happen again.

Previous: The Epigenetic Inheritance. Next: Adult Children of America.

Works cited

  1. Ackerman Institute for the Family. "Our History." https://www.ackerman.org/about-us/our-history/
  2. Spiro A, Schnurr PP, Aldwin CM. "Combat-related posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms in older men." Psychology and Aging, 1994. https://health.oregonstate.edu/sites/health.oregonstate.edu/files/char/military-life-course/publications/spiro_schnurr_aldwin_1994_combat-related_posttraumatic_stress_disorder_symptoms_in_older_men.pdf
  3. Mota N, Tsai J, Kirwin PD, et al. "Late-Life Exacerbation of PTSD Symptoms in US Veterans: Results From the National Health and Resilience in Veterans Study." Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 77(3):348-354, 2016. https://www.psychiatrist.com/jcp/late-life-ptsd-exacerbation/
  4. Terlizzi EP, Zablotsky B. "Mental Health Treatment Among Adults: United States, 2019." NCHS Data Brief No. 380, September 2020. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db380.htm