
Healing Together: When the Whole Family Does the Work
Chapter 13 of Generational Liberation. One person in therapy goes home to the same house. What happens when parent and child, or three generations, are treated together: what has been tested, what is still being tested, what culture and community add, and what a family can do without a program.
Published
Contents
Part IV, The Work. Chapter 13 of Generational Liberation: Healing the American Family.
Margaret, Paul and Lucy are a composite, drawn from patterns that recur in accounts of family therapy. They are not real people.
Lucy is ten, anxious, and quiet at school. Her father Paul, 48, brings her to a therapist and expects to sit in the waiting room.
The therapist asks to see him first.
Over several sessions Paul finds himself talking about his own father, who came home from the service and did not speak about it, and his mother, Margaret, who kept the house running and her feelings to herself. Paul learned early that the safe thing to do with a strong feeling was to leave the room. He has been leaving the room on Lucy.
Some weeks later Margaret, 73, is invited to a session. She listens to her son describe his childhood. Her first impulse is to tell him he is exaggerating. She does not. Near the end she says, "I didn't know how to give you what I never had."
Nothing is fixed that day. But Lucy now has a father who stays in the room, and Paul has a mother he can talk to. This chapter is about that way of working: treating the family and not only the person.
Why treat the family
Individual therapy has an obvious limit. The hour ends and the person goes home, to the same partner, the same parents, the same habits around the table. A child in treatment is in the most exposed position of all, because she cannot change the household she depends on.
Family therapists therefore start from a different assumption. The trouble is carried by one person, but it lives between people. A child's symptoms are often the visible part of a strain that runs through the whole house (see the "identified patient" in The Cycle Breakers).
The research in The Cycle Breakers supports the instinct. What weakened the passage of maltreatment from one generation to the next was the quality of the relationships around the parent, including those between adults.[1]
What has been tested
The best-studied treatment of this kind is Child-Parent Psychotherapy, for children under six who have lived through violence or other trauma. Parent and child are seen together. The therapist works on the relationship between them, and also on what the parent's own past is doing to it.
In a randomized trial with preschoolers who had witnessed violence between their parents, children who received it showed a greater drop in traumatic stress symptoms than those in a comparison group.[2] A national clearinghouse that grades child-welfare programs rates it 2 on a five-point scale where 1 is the strongest, meaning "Supported by Research Evidence."[3]
Two cautions. It is designed for young children, not for adult sons and their mothers. And it is a clinical treatment that takes many months, not a workshop.
Treating the parent first
Some programs go a step further and begin with the caregiver's own history before the child is seen at all. The reasoning is the same as on an aircraft: fit your own mask first. A parent who is thrown back into her own childhood every time her child cries cannot steady that child.
The idea is persuasive, and it is being put to a proper test. In the Netherlands, researchers have set up a randomized trial of a three-week program for adolescents exposed to family violence that combines trauma treatment for the young person with therapy for the parents and for the family together. It is being compared with the same intensive treatment without the family part, and with ordinary care. The published paper is the plan for the study. It reports no results.[4]
That is where this field stands. The logic is strong, the early signs are good, and much of it is still being measured. Be wary of any program that promises to heal two generations in a fixed number of weeks.
What culture and community add
Western therapy treats a person, or at most a household. Many communities have older ways of healing that treat a people.
The National Indian Health Board summarizes research showing that American Indian and Alaska Native children carry a heavier load of adversity than white children. In one national survey they were about twice as likely to have lived with substance abuse in the home or to have had a parent in jail.[5] The Board sets this against a history of land loss, forced assimilation and boarding schools.
The same summary reports something hopeful. In one study, caregivers who were strongly rooted in their Indigenous culture showed a weaker link between their own childhood adversity and their children's. Social support by itself protected less.[5] The Board recommends approaches built on traditional practice, elders, language and belonging.
The lesson reaches beyond Native communities. Belonging to something older and larger than your own family, a culture, a faith, a tradition, appears to be protective in its own right. It gives a person somewhere to stand that the family's troubles did not build.
Rooms where the generations already meet
Most people will never enter a formal family program. Many already have access to something related.
A twelve-step meeting of Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families, or of Al-Anon, usually has people in their twenties sitting beside people in their seventies. The older members are, in effect, other people's parents who have done the work. The younger ones are other people's children. Things can be said and heard across that gap that cannot yet be said at home.
This is not family therapy and does not claim to be. (This book is not affiliated with any fellowship.) But for someone whose own family will not come, it is the nearest available thing: a chosen family with every generation in it.
What a family can do without a program
- Start with whoever is willing. One person, then two. Do not wait for everyone.
- Invite, do not summon. "I'm seeing someone about how I grew up. Would you come to one session?"
- Ask the oldest for their story before you tell them yours. Four Generations, Four Languages for Pain sets out five steps for that conversation.
- Let the parent go first where children are involved. A calmer parent is the most direct help a child can get.
- Find a family therapist if you can. The American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy keeps a directory.
- Accept partial results. One honest conversation between a grandmother and her son is not a cure. It is still more than the family had.
Reader exercise
Take forty minutes. If it stirs up more than you expected, stop, and talk with someone you trust.
- Sketch three generations of your family. Beside each person write the part they played: the responsible one, the peacemaker, the problem, the one who left.
- What is one unspoken rule in your family? Who taught it to whom?
- Which single change, in which person, would make the most difference to the youngest generation?
- Is there a story from a grandparent's life that you have never asked for?
Resources
If you are in crisis: call or text 988.
- American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy: aamft.org
- National Child Traumatic Stress Network: nctsn.org
- Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families: adultchildren.org
- Al-Anon Family Groups: al-anon.org
- SAMHSA National Helpline: 1-800-662-4357
This chapter is educational. It is not medical advice.
Margaret did not set out to change. She came to support her son. Paul did not expect his mother to understand him. Lucy has no idea what was said in that room. She knows only that her father sits on the edge of her bed now and asks about her day, and waits for the answer.
Previous: Reparenting and the Nervous System. Next: The Inheritance We Choose.
Works cited
- Schofield TJ, Lee RD, Merrick MT. "Safe, Stable, Nurturing Relationships as a Moderator of Intergenerational Continuity of Child Maltreatment: A Meta-Analysis." Journal of Adolescent Health 53(4):S32-S38, 2013. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3784834
- National Institute of Justice, CrimeSolutions. "Program Profile: Child-Parent Psychotherapy," summarizing Lieberman AF, Van Horn P, Ghosh Ippen C, Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2005. https://crimesolutions.ojp.gov/ratedprograms/97
- California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse for Child Welfare. "Child-Parent Psychotherapy (CPP)." https://cebc4cw.org/implementation/child-parent-psychotherapy
- Fictorie V, Jonkman C, Visser M, Vandenbosch M, Steketee M, Schuengel C. "Effectiveness of a high-intensive trauma-focused, family-based therapy for youth exposed to family violence: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial." Trials 23:46, 2022. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8762952/
- National Indian Health Board. "Healing Frameworks: Understanding ACEs in Indigenous Communities." https://www.nihb.org/aces/