Workbench still life: a kraft envelope sketched with people seated in a circle and labeled See, Judge, Act, beside an open Bible, clay jug, bread and a lantern.

Gutiérrez and Liberation Theology

What liberation theology is, what Martín-Baró took from it and what he left, and how its ideas about people and power show up on this site: in a twelve-step fellowship's traditions, in a book about families, and in tools people run themselves. Includes the case against it.

Published

Contents
  1. Author's note
  2. What it is
  3. What Martín-Baró took, and what he left
  4. Why this Library cares
    1. ACA
    2. Generational Liberation
    3. Liberation Technology
  5. The argument about it
  6. Limits of the borrowing
  7. See also
  8. Works cited

Liberation theology is a movement in Latin American Christianity that reads the faith from the side of the poor. The psychology that followed Ignacio Martín-Baró borrowed its standpoint and its method without requiring its faith. This Library does the same.

This page explains what liberation theology is, what Martín-Baró took from it, and what the writing on this site takes from it in turn. It takes no position on whether the theology is true.

Author's note

I am agnostic. ACA gave me a higher power, which some people call God. What draws me to liberation theology is what it says about people and power.

George Aguiar

What it is

Gustavo Gutiérrez was a Peruvian priest and theologian. In July 1968 he gave a talk in Chimbote, Peru, called "Towards a Theology of Liberation". A month later the Latin American bishops met at Medellín, Colombia, and the movement is usually dated from that meeting. His book A Theology of Liberation came out in Spanish in 1971 and in English in 1973.[1][2]

The main ideas are these.

  • Start from poverty. The starting point is the structural poverty of Latin America. Theology begins in practice and in solidarity with the poor. Reflection is the second step.[3]
  • Poverty is made. The poor did not become poor by chance. They were impoverished by oppression and exploitation. Poverty is a sinful situation, not the will of God.[3]
  • The non-person. Western theology since the Enlightenment had been answering the non-believer. Liberation theology answers the non-person: the poor, the plundered, the people without a history.[3]
  • The preferential option for the poor. God speaks particularly through the poor, and the Bible is understood from where they stand. The bishops at Medellín adopted the language.[1][2]
  • Base communities. Local groups of ten to thirty people, led mostly by laypeople, studied the Bible together and worked on what their neighbors needed first: food, water, sewage, electricity.[2]
  • See, judge, act. A simple method from the Catholic Action movements that shaped Gutiérrez as a student.[1]

The work was dangerous. Governments called it communist infiltration of the church, and soldiers and death squads killed pastoral workers. Archbishop Oscar Romero of El Salvador was murdered at the altar in March 1980.[1] Nine years later the army killed six Jesuits at the Central American University, Ignacio Martín-Baró among them.

What Martín-Baró took, and what he left

Martín-Baró was a Jesuit as well as a psychologist. In his essay "Toward a Liberation Psychology" he named three things he took from liberation theology.[4]

  • A God of life. Faith sides with life, against whatever destroys it.
  • Practice before doctrine. What is done counts for more than what is correctly said.
  • The preferential option for the poor.

He then asked the same kind of question of his own field. What would psychology look like if it were seen from the place of the unemployed, the illiterate and the marginalized?[4]

The two share a standpoint and ask different questions. The table is a summary in this site's words.

Liberation theology

Liberation psychology

Question

How to speak of God where poverty means an early death

How oppression works in minds and communities, and how psychology has to change

Sources

Scripture, tradition, the faith of the poor, social analysis

People's experience, social analysis, psychological methods

Test of an idea

Faithful practice with the poor

Whether it helps people understand their situation and act

Setting

Church, base communities, pastoral work

Research, therapy, community projects

Whether the psychology can be separated from the theology is disputed. Sarah DeMarais argues that psychologists who build on Martín-Baró tend to treat his theology vaguely or wave it away, and that this is a loss. She reads him alongside his Jesuit community, above all Ignacio Ellacuría, for whom history was open and a place where God is present.[5]

This page takes the view that both things are true. The founder's psychology was grounded in his faith. The tradition that followed him does not have to be.

Why this Library cares

This section is interpretation. It is this site's reading, not a claim that any of the people or groups named would agree with it.

One idea runs through everything below: people, and power to the people. Liberation theology treats the poor as people who act, and not as people to be acted on. Its base communities were run by their own members.

ACA

Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families is a twelve-step fellowship. Its Twelve Traditions, adapted from those of Alcoholics Anonymous, name one authority for a group: a loving God as expressed through the group's own conscience. Leaders are trusted servants who "do not govern". Each group runs itself, pays its own way and stays non-professional.[6] The fellowship's commitment to service says the true power of the program rests in the membership of the meetings.[7]

A meeting and a base community are built alike. Both are small. Neither has an expert in the room. In both, people read their own lives together and decide for themselves what to do next.

They also differ, and the difference matters. ACA takes no position on outside issues.[6] It is not a church and it is not a political movement. Liberation theology is public and political by design. The comparison is this site's. No fellowship has made it, and this Library is not affiliated with or endorsed by any fellowship.

Generational Liberation

Generational Liberation: Healing the American Family makes two moves that liberation theology made first, in another setting.

  • Harm that is made, not chosen. Liberation theology calls poverty a sinful situation: real harm built into an arrangement, which no single person decided on. The book says something similar about families. A bundle is handed down, and nobody in the line set out to hurt anyone.
  • The non-person. Adult Children of America describes the lost child, who survives a troubled home by disappearing. That is a small, domestic version of a person denied a place and a history.

Liberation Technology

  • A design question. The option for the poor can be asked of any tool. Who is it for, and who runs it?
  • Run by its members. In the Shell of the Old is about free software and open hardware that movements build and operate themselves. That is the base community's principle applied to infrastructure.

One man stood near both worlds. Ivan Illich was a Catholic priest who founded a center called CIDOC in Cuernavaca, Mexico. Paulo Freire passed through it, and Gutiérrez attended its seminars.[8][9] In 1973 Illich published Tools for Conviviality, which argues for limiting our tools and for preferring the ones we can control over the ones that control us.[8] He was not a liberation theologian. A friend who knew him wrote that he did not write theology and that his Catholicism was very conservative.[10] He is a neighbor of this tradition, and the clearest bridge from it to the question of tools.

The argument about it

Liberation theology has been argued over since it began, and the argument is not finished.

The case against. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, then head of the Vatican's doctrinal office and later Pope Benedict XVI, issued critiques in 1984 and 1986 of the links between liberation theology and Marxism.[11] Gutiérrez and others had borrowed some elements of Marxist analysis to describe the lives of the poor.[1] The objection was that the movement had been politicized, especially by people sympathetic to Marxism.[12] Critics still hold that it was noble in intent and harmful in effect, and that it blamed impersonal structures for what comes from personal sin.[13]

The case for. Many of Gutiérrez's fellow theologians were investigated and disciplined. He was not.[14] Cardinal Gerhard Müller, a later head of the same Vatican office, called him one of the great theologians of the age and said the liberation he wrote about was theological before it was political. Pope Francis thanked him publicly in 2018.[12]

Where it stands. Gutiérrez died on October 22, 2024, at 96.[12] In October 2025 Pope Leo XIV, who spent more than two decades as a missionary and bishop in Peru, issued his first major teaching document, Dilexi Te. It draws heavily on Latin American theology and affirms the preferential choice for the poor.[15] Traditionalist critics answered that it turns charity into social theory.[16]

This Library does not settle that argument. It notes that the argument is about the faith and its politics, and that what this site borrows is narrower: a standpoint, and a habit of asking who holds the power.

Limits of the borrowing

  • A faith is not a toolkit. Taking the standpoint and leaving the faith is exactly what DeMarais warns against in psychology.[5] Believers may fairly say the same of this page.
  • A fellowship is not a movement. ACA's traditions keep it out of public controversy. Nothing here should be read as placing it in one.
  • An analogy is not a lineage. Martín-Baró's debt to liberation theology is history. The links drawn here to families and to technology are comparisons made by this site.

See also

Works cited

  1. Linden I. "Gustavo Gutierrez - Father of Liberation Theology." Independent Catholic News, 2024. https://www.indcatholicnews.com/news/50923
  2. "Liberation theology." Encyclopaedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/liberation-theology
  3. Tombs D. "Gustavo Gutiérrez and A Theology of Liberation." SCM Press, 2024. https://scmpress.hymnsam.co.uk/blog/gustavo-guti%C3%A9rrez-and-a-theology-of-liberation
  4. Martín-Baró I. Writings for a Liberation Psychology. Edited by Adrianne Aron and Shawn Corne. Harvard University Press, 1994.
  5. DeMarais S. "Reality, Truth, and Transcendence: The Theological Roots of Ignacio Martín-Baró's Liberation Psychology." Paper abstract, American Academy of Religion Annual Meeting, 2026. https://papers.aarweb.org/attached-paper/113172-reality-truth-and-transcendence-theological-roots-ignacio-martin-baros
  6. Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families World Service Organization. "The Twelve Traditions." https://adultchildren.org/literature/traditions/
  7. Adult Children of Alcoholics & Dysfunctional Families World Service Organization. "The Suggested Commitment to Service." https://adultchildren.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/Suggested_Commitment_EN_US_LTR.pdf
  8. McGuirk J. "What Is a 'Responsibly Limited Tool' in the Age of AI?" Los Angeles Review of Books, October 21, 2026. https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/ivan-illich-centenary-theory-labor-artificial-intelligence-humanity/
  9. "Accepting Limits." Review of Todd Hartch, The Prophet of Cuernavaca: Ivan Illich and the Crisis of the West. First Things. https://firstthings.com/accepting-limits/
  10. "Remembering Ivan Illich." First Things. https://firstthings.com/?p=13201
  11. Tinner-Williams N. "Fr Gustavo Gutiérrez, father of liberation theology, dead at 96." Black Catholic Messenger, October 2024. https://blackcatholicmessenger.org/fr-gustavo-gutierrez-obit
  12. OSV News. "Former doctrinal chief calls Father Gustavo Gutiérrez 'one of the great theologians of our time'." National Catholic Reporter, October 2024. https://www.ncronline.org/news/former-doctrinal-chief-calls-father-gustavo-gutierrez-one-great-theologians-our-time
  13. "Why Ratzinger and Wojtyła were correct about liberation theology." Catholic World Report, September 21, 2023. https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2023/09/21/why-ratzinger-and-wojtyla-were-correct-about-liberation-theology/
  14. "A Tribute to Gustavo Gutiérrez." Maryknoll Magazine, March 2025. https://www.maryknollmagazine.org/2025/03/a-tribute-to-gustavo-gutierrez/
  15. "Pope Leo blasts elitism, indifference toward poor in first major document." National Catholic Reporter, October 2025. https://www.ncronline.org/pope-leo-blasts-elitism-indifference-toward-poor-first-major-document
  16. Jackson C. "Dilexi Te: Preferential Option or Perilous Departure?" Big Modernism (Substack), 2025. https://bigmodernism.substack.com/p/dilexi-te-preferential-option-or